As confusion reigns over what exactly is happening with Google and Cookies, Christian J. Ward, Chief Data Officer at Yext says that prepare for cookies to go away and be ready for consumers to take control
If you’re feeling a bit dizzy trying to keep up with Google’s plans for third-party cookies, you’re not alone. Since their initial announcement in January 2020 to phase out third-party cookies within two years, Google has taken us on quite a journey. Multiple delays, shifts in strategy, and intense debates have marked the path—debates that have included everyone from brands and advertisers to privacy advocates.
But in July 2024, Google changed directions. Instead of eliminating third-party cookies altogether, they’ve introduced a new experience in Chrome that puts the decision squarely in the hands of consumers. With this update, users can easily toggle cookies on or off, giving them direct control over their web browsing privacy.
This approach is a clever one. It allows Google to avoid backlash from advertisers while effectively diminishing the role of cookies across the web. While the exact implementation has yet to be unveiled, there will likely be a very simple toggle for Chrome web browser users to completely turn off cookie tracking. Here’s what this means for brands and what we can expect in the years to come.
The cookie’s is still going away
The ongoing debate around cookies stems from Google’s balancing act—trying to satisfy privacy advocates while keeping advertisers happy. Over the past four years, Google has faced challenges in developing an alternative to cookies that advertisers and publishers can agree on.
With their latest move, Google is shifting the responsibility to consumers. By making it incredibly easy to opt out of cookies whenever they log into Chrome, Google is letting users decide the fate of third-party cookies. If a significant majority of users choose to turn off cookies, the effectiveness of cookies across the web will rapidly decline—not because Google enforced it, but because consumers did.
This strategy shields Google from the backlash it would otherwise face from advertisers and publishers, who have been slow to agree on viable alternatives. Instead, by placing the power directly in the hands of consumers, Google still achieves the same end result: a web where cookies are less effective and less pervasive.
Privacy at the forefront
Consumer awareness of online privacy has grown steadily in recent years, but the tools to control that privacy haven’t always been user-friendly. Turning off all tracking and cookies has often required navigating complex settings, if it was possible at all. Google’s new approach could change that, making privacy controls far more accessible and intuitive.
We’ve already seen how consumers react when given clear choices about their privacy. Studies on GDPR implementation and Apple’s device-level tracking options show that people overwhelmingly opt out of tracking when the option is clear and straightforward. Google’s new strategy is likely to follow this trend, significantly reducing the effectiveness of cookies across the web.
This shift also aligns with a broader trend we’re seeing across the tech industry: empowering consumers with more control over their data. Whether it’s Apple’s App Tracking Transparency or Europe’s GDPR regulations, the direction is clear—consumers want more say in how their data is collected and used, and they are increasingly choosing to opt out of invasive tracking.
Looking ahead: privacy and the future of search
So, what happens next? To understand the implications, we need to zoom out and consider the broader context of how we search online and how consumer behaviours are evolving.
Our relationship with search engines is becoming more conversational, driven by AI chatbots and large language models like ChatGPT and Google Gemini. In this new landscape, imagine simply telling your browser, “I don’t want to be tracked,” and having it instantly comply by disabling all cookies and tracking mechanisms. This is the future Google’s latest move hints at—a future where consumers have more control over what data they share and when.
But this isn’t just about restricting data sharing. It’s also about making it easier for consumers to turn tracking back on when it benefits them. Picture this: You’re in a new city and want recommendations for the best local coffee shops. You could simply ask your phone to share your location with nearby businesses—and just as easily turn off tracking when you no longer need it. As AI continues to evolve, these interactions will become increasingly voice-driven, further simplifying the process.
This scenario points to a future where the line between search and conversation blurs even further. We’re moving towards an era where your digital assistant will handle privacy settings as naturally as it manages your calendar or sends a text message. And this shift will fundamentally change how brands interact with consumers.
What this means for brands
Whether or not consumers choose to opt out of cookies, there are several key actions brands should take to adapt to this shifting landscape:
- Create better experiences: The future of data collection lies in zero-party data—information that consumers willingly share in exchange for something valuable. To encourage this, brands need to focus on creating seamless and enjoyable experiences. This might involve offering incentives like discounts in exchange for personal details shared through surveys or interactive content.
The key here is value exchange. Consumers are more likely to share their data if they see a clear benefit, whether it’s a personalised recommendation, a special offer, or a more convenient shopping experience. Brands that can deliver this kind of value will find it easier to build trust and collect the data they need.
- Prioritise transparency: Trust is the currency of the future. Brands must be transparent about how they collect and use data. By openly communicating these practices, brands not only build trust but also empower consumers to make informed decisions about sharing their data. This transparency is key to fostering a direct, trust-based relationship with customers.
In practical terms, this means going beyond the legal jargon in your privacy policy. It means communicating in plain language about what data you’re collecting, why you’re collecting it, and how it benefits the consumer. The more straightforward and honest you are, the more likely consumers are to trust you with their data.
- Embrace AI-driven dialogues: AI-powered tools will play a crucial role in this new landscape. By leveraging machine learning and conversational AI, brands can engage customers in meaningful dialogues, gathering zero-party data throughout the customer journey. This data can then be transformed into robust first-party datasets, helping brands understand and meet customer needs more effectively.
AI doesn’t just help with data collection; it can also enhance the customer experience by providing personalised recommendations, answering questions, and guiding users through their journey. By integrating AI into your customer interactions, you can create a more engaging and personalised experience, which in turn encourages consumers to share more data.
- Adapt to a cookie-less future: The decline of third-party cookies is inevitable, and brands need to prepare for a world where cookies are no longer the primary tool for tracking and personalisation. This means investing in alternative methods for understanding and engaging with your audience, such as first-party data collection, contextual advertising, and AI-driven insights.
It’s also important to recognise that this transition won’t happen overnight. There will be a period of adjustment as the industry shifts away from cookies, and brands that are proactive in adapting to this change will be better positioned to succeed in the long run.
Sweeping up the crumbs
Google’s latest move offers brands a golden opportunity to rethink how they interact with consumers. As privacy becomes a more prominent concern, consumers will be more conscious of how they share their personal data. In response, brands need to shift their focus toward building direct, trust-based relationships with their audiences.
By embracing zero-party data strategies, reducing reliance on third-party cookies, and using AI to facilitate meaningful exchanges, brands can create more valuable and personalised experiences for their customers. This isn’t just about surviving in a post-cookie world—it’s about thriving in a new era of digital marketing where trust and transparency are paramount.
The cookie may be crumbling, but the future is full of opportunities for those who are ready to adapt.
You are in: Home » Retail Media » GUEST COMMENT Google’s cookie conundrum – now consumers hold the power
GUEST COMMENT Google’s cookie conundrum – now consumers hold the power
Paul Skeldon
As confusion reigns over what exactly is happening with Google and Cookies, Christian J. Ward, Chief Data Officer at Yext says that prepare for cookies to go away and be ready for consumers to take control
If you’re feeling a bit dizzy trying to keep up with Google’s plans for third-party cookies, you’re not alone. Since their initial announcement in January 2020 to phase out third-party cookies within two years, Google has taken us on quite a journey. Multiple delays, shifts in strategy, and intense debates have marked the path—debates that have included everyone from brands and advertisers to privacy advocates.
But in July 2024, Google changed directions. Instead of eliminating third-party cookies altogether, they’ve introduced a new experience in Chrome that puts the decision squarely in the hands of consumers. With this update, users can easily toggle cookies on or off, giving them direct control over their web browsing privacy.
This approach is a clever one. It allows Google to avoid backlash from advertisers while effectively diminishing the role of cookies across the web. While the exact implementation has yet to be unveiled, there will likely be a very simple toggle for Chrome web browser users to completely turn off cookie tracking. Here’s what this means for brands and what we can expect in the years to come.
The cookie’s is still going away
The ongoing debate around cookies stems from Google’s balancing act—trying to satisfy privacy advocates while keeping advertisers happy. Over the past four years, Google has faced challenges in developing an alternative to cookies that advertisers and publishers can agree on.
With their latest move, Google is shifting the responsibility to consumers. By making it incredibly easy to opt out of cookies whenever they log into Chrome, Google is letting users decide the fate of third-party cookies. If a significant majority of users choose to turn off cookies, the effectiveness of cookies across the web will rapidly decline—not because Google enforced it, but because consumers did.
This strategy shields Google from the backlash it would otherwise face from advertisers and publishers, who have been slow to agree on viable alternatives. Instead, by placing the power directly in the hands of consumers, Google still achieves the same end result: a web where cookies are less effective and less pervasive.
Privacy at the forefront
Consumer awareness of online privacy has grown steadily in recent years, but the tools to control that privacy haven’t always been user-friendly. Turning off all tracking and cookies has often required navigating complex settings, if it was possible at all. Google’s new approach could change that, making privacy controls far more accessible and intuitive.
We’ve already seen how consumers react when given clear choices about their privacy. Studies on GDPR implementation and Apple’s device-level tracking options show that people overwhelmingly opt out of tracking when the option is clear and straightforward. Google’s new strategy is likely to follow this trend, significantly reducing the effectiveness of cookies across the web.
This shift also aligns with a broader trend we’re seeing across the tech industry: empowering consumers with more control over their data. Whether it’s Apple’s App Tracking Transparency or Europe’s GDPR regulations, the direction is clear—consumers want more say in how their data is collected and used, and they are increasingly choosing to opt out of invasive tracking.
Looking ahead: privacy and the future of search
So, what happens next? To understand the implications, we need to zoom out and consider the broader context of how we search online and how consumer behaviours are evolving.
Our relationship with search engines is becoming more conversational, driven by AI chatbots and large language models like ChatGPT and Google Gemini. In this new landscape, imagine simply telling your browser, “I don’t want to be tracked,” and having it instantly comply by disabling all cookies and tracking mechanisms. This is the future Google’s latest move hints at—a future where consumers have more control over what data they share and when.
But this isn’t just about restricting data sharing. It’s also about making it easier for consumers to turn tracking back on when it benefits them. Picture this: You’re in a new city and want recommendations for the best local coffee shops. You could simply ask your phone to share your location with nearby businesses—and just as easily turn off tracking when you no longer need it. As AI continues to evolve, these interactions will become increasingly voice-driven, further simplifying the process.
This scenario points to a future where the line between search and conversation blurs even further. We’re moving towards an era where your digital assistant will handle privacy settings as naturally as it manages your calendar or sends a text message. And this shift will fundamentally change how brands interact with consumers.
What this means for brands
Whether or not consumers choose to opt out of cookies, there are several key actions brands should take to adapt to this shifting landscape:
The key here is value exchange. Consumers are more likely to share their data if they see a clear benefit, whether it’s a personalised recommendation, a special offer, or a more convenient shopping experience. Brands that can deliver this kind of value will find it easier to build trust and collect the data they need.
In practical terms, this means going beyond the legal jargon in your privacy policy. It means communicating in plain language about what data you’re collecting, why you’re collecting it, and how it benefits the consumer. The more straightforward and honest you are, the more likely consumers are to trust you with their data.
AI doesn’t just help with data collection; it can also enhance the customer experience by providing personalised recommendations, answering questions, and guiding users through their journey. By integrating AI into your customer interactions, you can create a more engaging and personalised experience, which in turn encourages consumers to share more data.
It’s also important to recognise that this transition won’t happen overnight. There will be a period of adjustment as the industry shifts away from cookies, and brands that are proactive in adapting to this change will be better positioned to succeed in the long run.
Sweeping up the crumbs
Google’s latest move offers brands a golden opportunity to rethink how they interact with consumers. As privacy becomes a more prominent concern, consumers will be more conscious of how they share their personal data. In response, brands need to shift their focus toward building direct, trust-based relationships with their audiences.
By embracing zero-party data strategies, reducing reliance on third-party cookies, and using AI to facilitate meaningful exchanges, brands can create more valuable and personalised experiences for their customers. This isn’t just about surviving in a post-cookie world—it’s about thriving in a new era of digital marketing where trust and transparency are paramount.
The cookie may be crumbling, but the future is full of opportunities for those who are ready to adapt.
Read More
You may also like
Register for Newsletter
Receive 3 newsletters per week
Gain access to all Top500 research
Personalise your experience on IR.net